Hello dear
Welcome To Bella's Pizzeria
Welcome to Bella's Pizzeria, a cherished gem nestled in Casselberry, FL. Known for its authentic Italian pizzas and warm, inviting atmosphere, Bella's is a beloved local spot for families and pizza lovers alike. Owners Bella and Tony take pride in crafting each dish, ensuring the freshest ingredients and flavors. Diners rave about the homemade sauces, perfectly stretchy cheese, and signature Supreme Pies. The pizzeria excels in accommodating special requests, perfect for little ones who enjoy their veggies without the fuss. Frequented by loyal patrons, Bella’s offers not just exceptional food, but a sense of community and belonging.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
1 Topping
US$22.95Cheeseburger
US$11.50Grilled Chicken Salad
US$13.50
Spinach Salad
US$11.95Garlic Cheese Bread
US$6.50Sausages (2)
US$6.50
Meat Balls (2)
US$6.50Garlic Knots
US$5.95French Fries Small
US$4.75 About
Bella's Pizzeria
Welcome to Bella's Pizzeria, where every bite transports you straight to the heart of Italy. Nestled in Casselberry, FL, at 500 FL-436, Bella's is not just another pizza place—it’s a beloved local gem cherished by families looking for authentic Italian cuisine. Renowned for its warm atmosphere, Bella's has quickly become a favorite spot for pizza lovers of all ages.
As soon as you step inside, the welcoming ambiance envelops you. The dedicated owners, Bella and Tony, not only serve delicious food but also offer an experience filled with genuine hospitality. Many visitors have shared their positive encounters with the couple, reflecting their commitment to superior customer service. One satisfied customer mentioned, “Came in 30 minutes before closing...but was not an issue for the nice owner operator couple.” It's this kind of warmth that makes Bella's feel like home.
But let's get to the star of the show— the food. Bella's is renowned for its mouthwatering pizzas. Customers rave about the Supreme Pies, with one even dreaming about them! The pizzas are meticulously crafted, featuring perfect stretchy cheese, a homemade sauce that brings out the best flavors, and a crust that strikes the right balance between thin and crispy. If you're craving something different, don’t miss out on their Stromboli, praised for its incredible taste and authentic Italian flair.
Another highlight is the accommodating nature of the chefs; they happily cater to special requests, ensuring even the pickiest eaters enjoy their meals, as noted by a customer who appreciated how they diced the veggies for her granddaughter.
Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or celebrating a family movie night, Bella's Pizzeria offers a dining experience that makes your taste buds dance. With great sales and superb food, this local pizzeria promises to earn a special spot in your heart—and your stomach. Don’t just take our word for it; pop in and taste the magic at Bella's!
For a taste of authentic Italian pizza in Casselberry, call Bella's Pizzeria at +1 407-237-0996 and discover what makes them a local legend.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ A great experience trying out Bella’s pizzeria yesterday! Came in 30 minutes before closing but was not an issue for the nice owner operator couple Bella and Tony. Very welcoming and homey feel to the establishment, great customer service from the cute cashier, and superb food. We got the white pizza with garlic and it did not disappoint! ”
“ I just love this place and was so sad to see them have to relocate over to Casselberry. But, neither here nor there, it is still my families go to local Mom & Pop family Pizzaria, that we frequent whenever it's movie night and we are in the mood for a great Italian made pizza. Their pizzas taste authentic and the real deal. I dream about their Surpreme Pies. Yummo! They are also very amiable to special requests. My 7yo loves Pizza, but hates when the toppings are too big and chunky and the chefs there have no problem accommodating Grandma's request to dice all the veggies into very small pieces. My Granddaughter eats it up and doesn't even realize how many good veggies she's getting in her diet. Thanks a Million Bella's! ”
“ The food here is consistently great. Bella is a great hostess and tends to all of your needs. Everyone in your party will find something on the menu that they like. Definitely a place to try if you’ve never been before ”
“ I was here on Monday night and it was amazing! My family and I got a bunch of entrees to share and their Stromboli is amazing! The sauce is homemade and the atmosphere is so authentic and inviting. I recommend 5/5 and will be coming here often :) ”
“ Great pizza, wings, salads. Bella & Tony are awesome. Make sure you visit when you are in Casselberry ”
“ 5 stars across the board for Bella’s Pizzeria!! The food is so amazing, this has been our go-to pizza place ever since the first time we tried it. The owners are so kind, and caring, and I love supporting their business! Excellent quality through and through. We are so happy we found this place! ”
“ Absolutely incredible pies! If you’re from the northeast and miss your neighborhood pizza spot, eat here! I’m from New York and I’ve lived in Florida for 20 years. I’ve never had pizza in Florida so good. Perfect stretchy cheese, right amount of sauce, thin + perfectly cooked crust, and greasy in the best way. It was exact right amount of salty and sweet as well without being too much of either. The owners are both friendly and warm and have pride in their food. This is a great small business that I’m so glad I stumbled across. They just earned themselves a new regular! ”
“ The food here is delicious and huge portions. The pizza crust is great. Homemade. Prices a fair. A lot great food at fair prices. I recommend this place 100% We tried the Philly steak cheese pizza. Egg plant parmiggian, pasta and meat bowls. Everything was excellent! ”